In the upper-school common room a teacher pins small coloured subject cards into columns on a large board, while two older students with their choice slips point at where their two subjects sit in different columns.
← All articlesPractice

How to build option blocks from student choices

Option blocks decide which subject combinations a student can actually take. Here is a method that works on paper: start from the real choices, count which subjects share students, test every combination, and know your three ways out when someone does not fit. With a worked example, and a section on IB HL and SL.

BBildena team · · 9 min read

To build option blocks, start from the choices students actually made, not from last year's blocks. Collect the choices, count how many students want each subject and how many want each pair of subjects, decide how many groups each subject runs, and put subjects that share students into different blocks. Then test every student's combination. Only after that check teachers, rooms and the week. When a student still does not fit, you have three ways out: a second group of one subject, one more block, or a conversation with the student about their reserve choice.

An option block is a set of classes that run at the same time, so a student can take one class from each block. Schools also call them option columns, option lines, elective pools or bands. The method below works for GCSE options, A levels and the IB Diploma, and it needs no special software. What software adds is a search through far more layouts than anyone can try by hand; we come to that at the end.

Why it pays to do this carefully

The number of possible layouts is far beyond what anyone can try by hand. Rhyd Lewis, who works on this problem, counts 10,306,752 ways to arrange just 13 subjects into up to five columns. And the layout is not a detail of the timetable: it decides which combinations exist at all. A student who wants Physics and History cannot take both if they sit in the same block, however good the rest of the week is.

What you need before you start

  • Each student's choices, ideally a first set plus a reserve. Reserve choices are what you fall back on later.
  • The rules of the combination: how many subjects each student takes, and anything compulsory.
  • Group sizes: the largest group a room and a teacher can take, and the smallest you can afford to run.
  • Who can teach what, and how many hours each of them has left after the lower years.
  • The time you have: how many periods a week one block takes, and how many blocks fit.

A worked example

Here is a made-up cohort: 40 students, three subjects each, seven subjects on offer, three blocks in the week, and at most 24 students in a group.

CombinationStudents
Maths, Chemistry, Biology9
Maths, Chemistry, Physics8
Maths, Physics, Economics5
Maths, Economics, History7
Biology, Chemistry, History3
Economics, History, Art4
History, Art, Biology4

Step 1: Count each subject and set the number of groups

Maths 29, Chemistry 20, History 18, Biology 16, Economics 16, Physics 13, Art 8. With 24 to a group, Maths needs two groups. Everything else fits in one, for now.

Step 2: Count the pairs

For each pair of subjects, count the students who chose both. This one table does most of the work:

BioCheEcoHisMatPhy
Art404800
Bio120790
Che03178
Eco11125
His70
Mat13

A zero means two subjects can share a block without hurting anyone. A large number means they must not. Mathematicians will recognise this as graph colouring: subjects are points, shared students are lines between them, and each block is a colour.

Step 3: Draw a first layout

Place the biggest numbers first. Chemistry and Maths share 17 students, so they go apart. Biology and Chemistry share 12, so they go apart too. A popular subject with two groups can sit in two different blocks, which helps twice: it solves the class size, and it gives students a second time to take it.

Block 1Block 2Block 3
Art (4)History (14)Biology (16)
Chemistry (20)Maths (9)Maths (20)
Economics (12)Physics (13)

Step 4: Test every student

Go through the combinations one at a time. Six of the seven work. The four students who chose Economics, History and Art do not: Economics and Art are both in Block 1. That is 36 of 40, and it also leaves Art with only four students.

We solved this little example exactly, and 36 is the most that any layout can serve with these groups and three blocks. By hand you would not know that, which is the honest limit of the paper method: you can tell a layout is good, not that it is the best.

Step 5: Choose a way out

You have three options, and each has a price:

  • A second group of one subject. Add a History group and rearrange, and all 40 students are served. It costs one more group of teaching.
  • A fourth block. This also reaches 40 of 40, with one group of everything except Maths. It costs more of the week, and it leaves every student with a free block.
  • The reserve choice. Keep three blocks and talk to the four students. It costs nothing in staffing, and for those four it may cost a subject they wanted.

Here is the layout with a second History group:

Block 1Block 2Block 3
Economics (16)Art (8)Biology (16)
History (7)Chemistry (20)History (11)
Maths (17)Maths (12)Physics (13)

Notice that adding one group moved several other subjects too. That is normal, and it is why you test the whole cohort again after every change, not only the students you were trying to help. The smallest group is now seven. If your minimum is eight, you are back to deciding what that group is worth.

Check teachers and rooms

A layout that works for students can still fail in the staffroom. Before you publish it, check these:

  • No teacher in two groups of one block. Two groups in different blocks can share a teacher; two groups in the same block cannot.
  • Other year groups. A teacher in Block 1 is not free for Year 10 in those periods. Look at the blocks of the years above and below together.
  • Specialist rooms. No block should need more labs or art rooms at once than you have. Our post on rooms in the school timetable shows how to count this.
  • Part-time staff. A block that always falls on someone's free day does not work for that teacher. See part-time teachers in the timetable.

IB Diploma: when HL and SL need different hours

The IB recommends 240 teaching hours for a higher-level subject and 150 for a standard-level one, and each student takes three or four subjects at higher level. Over two years of 34 teaching weeks, that is about 3.5 and 2.2 hours a week, so with 60-minute periods you would round up to four and three. Your own number depends on your effective weeks, so calculate it, and do not copy it from here.

Different hours mean blocks of different widths, and there are two usual ways to handle them:

  • Separate HL and SL groups. Each level runs in a block of its own width. This is simple, but it takes more groups, which a small cohort may not have.
  • Shared lessons plus HL-only periods. HL and SL students are taught together in a block, and HL students get extra periods on top. This saves groups, but the HL-only periods are a block problem of their own: a student with three HL subjects needs three extra periods that do not clash.

Every Diploma student takes Theory of Knowledge, so it belongs outside the blocks. Give it its own fixed time before you start. The same thinking applies to a subject that takes up two blocks, such as a double award: it sits in two columns, and a student who takes it has one choice fewer.

Fit the blocks into the week

Once the layout holds, a block behaves like one big lesson: every group in it meets in the same periods. Decide each block's pattern, for example two doubles and a single, and keep the doubles where practical subjects need them. Our post on doubles and blocks covers how that spread affects the week. Publish the blocks to students only once this works: a block you have announced is hard to move.

Common mistakes

  • Reusing last year's blocks. They fit last year's students.
  • Fixing a block for one subject's convenience early on, before you have seen the pair table.
  • Counting subjects but not combinations. Each subject can have enough students while one combination has nowhere to go.
  • Testing only the students you moved. One change can strand someone else.
  • Forgetting the change of mind. Students change subjects in September. Leave a little room in the groups, and know what you will do.

Doing it with a tool

For a small cohort, a spreadsheet with the pair table is enough. For more students, Rhyd Lewis offers a free Excel tool that takes ranked preferences and looks for the layout that satisfies the most choices.

In Bildena option blocks are called bands. Students hand in their choices in Plan › Course choice. Plan › Bands then suggests how many bands you need from the rules of the choice and the hours, and builds the plan: how many groups each course gets, which band each group sits in, and which student goes into which group. Groups stay between their minimum and maximum size, a named teacher never gets two groups of one band, and a course only goes into a band with its hours, so advanced and basic levels such as HL and SL each get bands of the right width. Whatever cannot be placed appears under Not placed with the reason. You can then add a band, allow one more group, pin a group or move a student, and let Bildena arrange the rest. When you accept the plan it becomes the year group's lessons, and the timetable places each band on the week.

Know the limits. This runs for schools with an upper school in their profile, with choice rounds from Year 10 and band plans from Year 11, so it suits A levels and the IB Diploma. A Year 9 round for GCSE options is not covered: for those, work out the blocks with the method above and enter them by hand as elective blocks, whose lessons are then locked to the same slot. Bildena checks counts, not your curriculum's rules, so it will not tell you that a combination breaks an IB requirement. It is also new on the market and has no reference schools to name yet.

You can do the same steps in the chat. Tell the assistant "Build Year 13's bands", "Arrange Year 12's bands again" or "Accept Year 12's plan", and it shows what will happen on a card; nothing changes until you press it. It follows each person's role, so it can only do what that person could do on the screen. It is free for every school, and the school can switch it off.

Course choice and bands come with Bildena Scheduler Pro and with Bildena School, which includes the timetable. See pricing for the current prices.

Frequently asked questions

How many option blocks do we need?

At least as many as the number of subjects each student takes. One more block gives you room, as the example shows, but it uses more of the week and gives each student a free block.

Should students choose before or after the blocks are published?

Before, wherever you can. The best layout for the real choices serves at least as many students as any layout fixed in advance. If you must publish blocks first, ask for reserve choices, and be ready to adjust.

Can HL and SL students be taught together?

Yes, with shared lessons and extra HL-only periods. Those extra periods then need their own clash check, because a student has several HL subjects.

What if a group ends up too small?

Decide its minimum before you start, so the decision is not made under pressure. Then you can move students to their reserve choice, merge groups, or run the small group and accept the cost.


Bring last year's real choices to the free month: every feature, your own data, no card needed. See how close your blocks were to what those students wanted.

Option blocksCourse choiceIB DiplomaTimetabling